Law Office of Tim Powers
If you practice in Denton County, you may not know this, but the subpoenas
criminal cases involving family violence (domestic violence) by the District and County Clerks offices contain language which inadvertently
coerces a person into compliance. The subpoenas state that refusal to
answer a subpoena could result in the person being arrested and/or fined.
The subpoena cites Texas Civil Rules of Procedure 176.8 which authorizes
punishment by contempt for failing to obey a subpoena.
Specifically, Rule 176.8 states that failure to comply with a subpoena will result
in a punishment of up to 180 days confinement and a fine up to $500. This
language inclusion, as well as the punishment for failure to answer, is
Read The Fine Print
In the case styled,
In re Dotson, 76 S.W.3d 393, 396 (Tex.Crim.App.,2002), the Texas Court of Criminal
Appeals held that failure to answer a subpoena does not fall under the
provisions of civil Rule 176.8 but instead, the penalty for failure to
answer a subpoena in a criminal case is limited to the provisions of Texas
Code of Criminal Procedure Art. 24.05. Art. 24.05 states that the only
punishment which could be imposed for refusing to obey a subpoena in a
criminal case is a fine not to exceed $500 in felony cases and $100 in
misdemeanors. The court rationed that since the subpoena was issued in
a criminal case, the court held that the correct statute to apply is the
statute which is the statute specific to such failure, Art. 24.05.
In re Dotson, 76 S.W.3d at 396.
Thus, the next time a witness fails to answer a subpoena in a domestic violence
case, the only penalty for the failure to answer is a fine not to exceed
$500 in felony cases and $100 in misdemeanors. No one is advocating that
a witness fail to obey a subpoena validly issued. However, falsely stating
the possible punishment is inappropriate. Could this falsity be interpreted
as "falsifying a government document" ?
You be the judge.
If you are seeking aggressive
criminal representation by an experienced
criminal defense attorney for your Denton County family violence case or arrest in Denton County,
contact the Law Offices of Tim Powers today. There is no charge or obligation for the initial consultation.
*Tim Powers is an attorney licensed to practice law by the Supreme Court
of Texas. Nothing in this article is intended to be legal advice. For
legal advice about any specific legal question you should directly consult